When Should I Replace My Dog's Favorite Toy?

Dog toys are more than just fun—they play a key role in your pup’s mental stimulation, physical activity, and emotional comfort. At Tank Dog Toys, we know how much your dog loves their favorite plush or chew, but it’s important to know when that toy needs to be cleaned—or replaced entirely.

Start with a Good Clean

Before tossing any toy in the trash, start with cleaning. Plush toys can often be washed in a gentle laundry cycle, while rubber toys can be soaked and scrubbed with pet-safe cleaners. Interactive or smart toys may require surface cleaning only, depending on electronic components.

However, if a toy can’t be cleaned properly, or begins to pose a health risk, it’s time to replace it.

Signs It’s Time to Replace Your Dog’s Toys

1. Plush Toys
These are often the first to wear out. If the stuffing is falling out, seams are split, or parts like eyes or buttons are loose, it’s time to toss it. Dirty plush toys that retain moisture or develop odors may also be harboring bacteria, even after washing.

2. Rubber Chew Toys
Chewed down rubber or plastic toys can become jagged, cracked, or small enough to pose a choking hazard. If your dog has gnawed the toy into smaller pieces, or if it’s no longer the original shape, it’s safer to replace it than risk injury.

Get a Discount on All Freezbone Products

3. Interactive and Smart Toys
These toys are great for enrichment, but over time the mechanics can wear out or break. If the toy no longer functions properly, if batteries leak, or if internal parts are exposed, it’s no longer safe for your dog. Additionally, if the toy can’t be cleaned or starts to smell even after wiping it down, it may be time to upgrade.

Remote Control Chase Ball

4. Age-Appropriateness
A toy that was perfect for your puppy may not be safe for your adult dog. Puppy toys are often softer and smaller—great for little mouths, but dangerous for bigger dogs who can tear them apart easily or swallow parts. Always reassess your dog’s toys as they grow.

Upgrade Your Dog’s Toy Box

Don’t wait for a safety issue. Keep your dog’s toy collection fresh and fun with durable, updated options. At Tank Dog Toys, we specialize in tough-tested plush, ultra-durable rubber, and engaging interactive toys designed to stand up to your dog’s play style.

Rope and Rubber Ball Combo

👉 Ready to upgrade? Browse our latest collection and replace those tired, worn-out toys with something stronger, cleaner, and safer today!